Propane vs Charcoal Grill Taste Test
Good Mythical Morning·1,053,096 views·Jul 17, 2026Score and analysis
Summary
Rhett McLaughlin and Link Neal compare propane versus charcoal grilling methods across steak, shrimp skewers, corn on the cob, chicken thighs, hot dogs, and burgers.The hosts engage in blind taste tests with escalating stakes, such as losing the ability to sense thermostat changes or say 'that's what she said.' Ultimately, charcoal is favored for most items, with steak and burgers showing a distinct preference for charcoal, while shrimp skewers are deemed better on gas.The episode concludes with Rhett winning $5,000 for Reading Is Fundamental, reinforcing the value of charcoal grilling for flavor.
8.1
VIDSCORE
Summary
Rhett McLaughlin and Link Neal compare propane versus charcoal grilling methods across steak, shrimp skewers, corn on the cob, chicken thighs, hot dogs, and burgers.The hosts engage in blind taste tests with escalating stakes, such as losing the ability to sense thermostat changes or say 'that's what she said.' Ultimately, charcoal is favored for most items, with steak and burgers showing a distinct preference for charcoal, while shrimp skewers are deemed better on gas.The episode concludes with Rhett winning $5,000 for Reading Is Fundamental, reinforcing the value of charcoal grilling for flavor.
Breakdown
Energy & Vibe
8.5
Rhett and Link maintain a consistently high level of energy and enthusiasm throughout the 23-minute episode.Their banter is rapid-fire, and their reactions to the food and the challenges are always animated.The pacing remains dynamic, moving briskly between the different food comparisons and discussions.
Satisfying Payoff
8.5
Each round of the grilling comparison concludes with a clear reveal of which method produced the better result, directly linking back to the stakes introduced.The final summary reinforces the overall findings, with Rhett McLaughlin earning a significant charity donation.The episode provides satisfying resolutions to each taste test and the overarching grilling debate.
Fresh & Original
5.7
The core concept of comparing propane and charcoal grilling is a common topic, but the execution adds unique elements.The show introduces specific stakes for each round, such as losing the ability to sense thermostat changes or say 'that's what she said,' which elevates the format beyond a simple taste test.The hosts' distinct personalities and established rapport also lend a unique flavor to the content.
Joke Quality
9.0
The hosts employ a mix of observational humor about grilling and playful banter, often escalating with absurd stakes for incorrect guesses.Their reactions to the food, particularly when struggling to differentiate between the two grilling methods, are genuinely funny.The recurring 'dad privilege' gags and the hosts' self-aware commentary contribute to the comedic tone.
Production Quality
8.2
The video features clear audio and well-lit scenes throughout the grilling comparisons.Visuals remain steady, and the editing effectively transitions between segments and taste tests.The overall presentation is clean and professional, supporting the content without distraction.
Entertainment Value
9.0
Rhett and Link engage in a lively debate about propane versus charcoal grilling, incorporating playful stakes like losing dad privileges.The segment structure, moving through different foods with escalating consequences, keeps viewers invested.Their banter and genuine reactions to the food create an engaging viewing experience.
Click any metric to see why it scored this way
Use VidScore on YouTube
Explore scores and profiles while you browse.
Get the ExtensionRelated videos
More videos we scored on the same topics.
5.8
22:32
Will It Chicken Fingers? (Taste Test)
Good Mythical Morning
5.6
20:09
Trying The Most Underrated Fast Food Items
Good Mythical Morning
5.3
11:30
THE PIE CHALLENGE THAT NOBODY HAS MANAGED TO CONQUER…IN A PACKED OUT PUB! | BeardMeatsFood
BeardMeatsFood
5.0
14:07
NOBODY HAS EVER BEATEN 'THE EIGHTH WONDER OF THE WORLD' CHALLENGE! | BeardMeatsFood
BeardMeatsFood
7.6
29:43
Best & Worst Dinner Service of Season 12 | Hell's Kitchen
Hell's Kitchen
7.6
46:33
I Ate EVERY Burger in America
Max the Meat Guy
7.2
24:38
I Tested America's Worst 1-Star Fast Food
Joshua Weissman
7.0
31:01
Gordon Ramsay Savagely Critiques Spicy Wings | Hot Ones
First We Feast
6.4
36:46
I Cooked Every EXOTIC Wagyu Steak
Max the Meat Guy
5.1
49:59
We Cooked Celebrities' Struggle Meals
Mythical Kitchen
8.4
25:14
I Tricked the Internet with Diabolical Food Hacks
Addie Bowley
7.7
21:12
