Kidnapped at the Dollar Store: Exposing Indiana’s Most Violent Predator
Real Crime·5,192 views·Aug 1, 2026Score and analysis
Summary
The documentary details the investigation into the murder of 10-year-old Katie Coleman, who disappeared while running an errand in Kruthersville, Indiana.Investigators faced challenges, including a false confession from Charles Hickman, before forensic evidence like DNA from a cigarette butt and semen identified Anthony Stocklman as the perpetrator.The case highlights the critical role of DNA analysis in solving complex crimes.Anthony Stocklman was ultimately sentenced to life without parole for the murder and sexual assault of Katie Coleman.
6.1
VIDSCORE
Summary
The documentary details the investigation into the murder of 10-year-old Katie Coleman, who disappeared while running an errand in Kruthersville, Indiana.Investigators faced challenges, including a false confession from Charles Hickman, before forensic evidence like DNA from a cigarette butt and semen identified Anthony Stocklman as the perpetrator.The case highlights the critical role of DNA analysis in solving complex crimes.Anthony Stocklman was ultimately sentenced to life without parole for the murder and sexual assault of Katie Coleman.
Breakdown
Deep Analysis
6.6
The documentary explores the impact of Katie Coleman's murder on the small community of Kruthersville, detailing the fear and outrage that followed.It also delves into the complexities of the investigation, including the initial false confession and the meticulous forensic work required to identify the correct suspect, Anthony Stocklman.
Engaging Delivery
6.6
The documentary effectively uses storytelling to build tension throughout the investigation, from Katie's disappearance to the eventual identification and arrest of Anthony Stocklman.The inclusion of interviews with investigators and family members, combined with the unfolding of the case's twists and turns, keeps the viewer invested.
Fair & Balanced
3.9
The documentary presents the facts of the case, including the initial false confession of Charles Hickman and the subsequent investigation that led to Anthony Stocklman's arrest.While recounting emotional events, it focuses on the investigative process and legal proceedings, presenting information from various participants in the case.
Fresh Insights
6.2
The documentary details the investigative process, including the challenges faced by law enforcement, such as the false confession from Charles Hickman and the eventual reliance on DNA evidence.It highlights how forensic science, specifically DNA analysis from cigarette butts and semen, ultimately identified Anthony Stocklman as the perpetrator.
Strong Evidence
6.6
The investigation relies on multiple forms of evidence, including eyewitness accounts, forensic analysis of the crime scene and victim's body, and DNA profiling.
Production Quality
6.5
The video uses a mix of archival footage, interviews, and on-scene reporting to tell the story of Katie Coleman's disappearance and murder.The editing maintains a clear chronological flow, and the audio quality is generally consistent across different segments, allowing the narrative to progress without significant distraction.
Clear Takeaways
6.5
The documentary concludes with the sentencing of Anthony Stocklman to life without parole for the murder and sexual assault of Katie Coleman.It summarizes the key evidence, including DNA findings and the cigarette butt match, that led to his conviction, providing a definitive resolution to the case.
Click any metric to see why it scored this way
Use VidScore on YouTube
Explore scores and profiles while you browse.
Get the ExtensionRelated videos
More videos we scored on the same topics.
7.1
46:10
He Put Her Body Through A Wood Chipper To Avoid Divorce
Real Crime
6.1
1:35:17
The Horrifying Story of Daniel LaPlante
The Casual Criminalist
8.3
1:09:34
Husband Claims Flying Pipe Killed His Wife!? The Case Of Barbara Kendhammer
Kendall Rae
5.5
43:01
"I Hate Blondes": Inside the Mind of "Bus Stop" Serial Killer
Real Crime
8.0
35:19
Cops Find Missing Pregnant Girl Dead
Law&Crime Network
6.5
1:13:48
The USF Double Student Homicide: The Case Of Zamil Limon & Nahida Bristy
Kendall Rae
6.5
1:10:45
Kohberger Backtracks, ‘Netflix Trend Murder’, Nolan Wells Audio Released & D4vd Going to Trial
Annie Elise
6.0
14:10
The Reddit Serial Killer Has Been Caught...
SomeOrdinaryGamers
5.9
21:49
Cop kills teen, ditches body in suitcase
True Crime News
5.7
42:51
Serial Killer’s TikTok Videos Accidentally Reveal His Horrifying Secrets
Coffeehouse Crime
5.7
2:34:36
Ashes in the River: The Perfect Concealment?
Best Documentary
5.6
21:24
