This Ship Is Dividing Everyone
Cruise With Ben and David·91,910 views·Jul 26, 2026Score and analysis
Summary
Ben and David review the Icon of the Seas, a massive 10,000-passenger cruise ship, addressing common complaints about overcrowding and scale.They share their six-night experience, detailing issues like crowded pool decks and busy venues, while also highlighting the ship's extensive amenities and entertainment.The hosts offer practical advice for navigating the ship and managing crowds, suggesting booking strategies and alternative times for activities.Ultimately, they conclude the Icon of the Seas offers significant value for its price, though they recommend older ships for budget-conscious travelers.
6.0
VIDSCORE
Summary
Ben and David review the Icon of the Seas, a massive 10,000-passenger cruise ship, addressing common complaints about overcrowding and scale.They share their six-night experience, detailing issues like crowded pool decks and busy venues, while also highlighting the ship's extensive amenities and entertainment.The hosts offer practical advice for navigating the ship and managing crowds, suggesting booking strategies and alternative times for activities.Ultimately, they conclude the Icon of the Seas offers significant value for its price, though they recommend older ships for budget-conscious travelers.
Breakdown
Alternatives & Context
4.9
Ben and David compare the Icon of the Seas to other cruise ships, referencing 'Oasis class ships' and 'older Royal Caribbean ships' when discussing pricing and value.They also mention other cruise lines like Celebrity and MSC when discussing infinite balcony cabins.
Honest & Unbiased
5.2
While the video is sponsored by Ekster, Ben and David clearly disclose this and integrate the advertisement separately.They present both common complaints and their own experiences, acknowledging subjective preferences while addressing objective issues like venue size and booking systems.
Covers Everything
6.5
The video covers a wide range of common complaints about large cruise ships, including overcrowding, noise, dining, pool decks, and navigation.Ben and David address each point with their own experiences and offer practical advice for potential cruisers.
Real Testing
6.7
Ben and David spent six nights on the Icon of the Seas, detailing their experiences with various venues, dining, and onboard activities.They address common complaints by sharing their personal observations and practical advice for navigating the ship's size and crowds.
Helps You Decide
6.7
Ben and David conclude that while the Icon of the Seas is an expensive option, it offers significant value for those seeking a unique experience, with many included amenities.They advise budget-conscious travelers to consider older ships in the Royal Caribbean fleet.
Production Quality
6.8
Ben and David present their review of the Icon of the Seas with clear on-screen visuals and consistent audio throughout the long-form video.The footage captures various ship locations and activities, aiding the viewer's understanding of their points.
Click any metric to see why it scored this way
Use VidScore on YouTube
Explore scores and profiles while you browse.
Get the ExtensionRelated videos
More videos we scored on the same topics.
5.9
56:54
We Tried The World's Biggest Disney Cruise Ship 🚢
2Passports 1Dream
7.2
20:34
Disney Cruise Line Changed My Mind About Cruises
DFBGuide
5.7
21:04
Is an Alaska Cruise Actually Worth It? (My First Cruise)
Currently Hannah
5.7
21:22
Travel Day to JAPAN ✈️ Premium Economy London LHR to Tokyo Haneda HND ✈️ ANA Flight NH212
Cakes with Faces
8.2
13:39
The BEST Checked Luggage for 2026 (Tested Head to Head)
Away Together w/ Nik and Allie
7.6
56:33
Etihad Airways First Class A380 Apartment | Amazing Flight from Abu Dhabi to Tokyo
ST Travel
6.5
14:37
Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 8 Real-World Test
TheUnlockr
6.0
22:55
Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 8! Day in the Life Review!
Katarina Mogus
5.8
17:50
Why Britain's Favourite Holiday Airline still flies these ANCIENT Jets
Wingin’ It! Paul Lucas
5.7
16:59
RWANDAIR Economy Class: How Is This Okay? 🇷🇼
The Flip Flop Traveller
8.2
31:57
I Spent 2 Days on Vietnam's Iconic Train and This Happened
Chloé and sometimes Ludvig
7.7
27:23
